So, I have the droid x and I really like it. The size is great to use but not great to have in your pocket. I am afraid if I return it and get an incredible I will miss the big screen but love the ease of storage. It really is a tough call. I do not have any issues with the x other than all of the apps it comes with that you CANNOT delete. I hate that. Its like buying a shirt with the companies logo on it. I was not paid to advertise for them.... LOL
My reception was actually good I thought. I did sell my X on Ebay yesterday and ordered a droid incredible. Size was the factor for me. No need for big screen as I will not be watching video on my phone. So, incredible hits the sweet spot for size in a pocket and still a great device.
Ok, so I took this thing camping in an area that's notoriously bad for Verizon. On my e815, the king of all that is reception, I got 2 bars and it was usable. On the Incredible, I got 1 bar and was also usable.
So, perhaps this reception issue is blown all out of proportions.