CES coverage: feedback?
We tried something new for our show coverage this year. What did you guys think of it? We're eager to hear what you thought of both the format and the content.
I was a little disappointed you guys didn't cover the Android tablets at all, especially given that they all seem to be tied to carriers. But I am sure the reasoning is sound, this is phonescoop, not tablet scoop.
One thing I missed from the past formats, though, and maybe I am remembering wrongly here and thus this is a suggestion in that case, having the tabs on the top that let you pick different manufacturers. I like to look at each brands line up more than this phone, then that phone, then another phone, all from a different brand. Especially when each brand has 3 different phones that are all similar, but have a few differences, make...
You've discussed your opinion against including tablets among the devices you review, but how strongly do you feel on that position?
You, of all people here, have a great understanding of the wireless world and most likely the direction it's going in. It just seems logical to include tablets into the website, considering that they are starting to take off and likely will become synonymous with the wireless data market.
It's no personal bias that I have, considering the fact that I neither own, nor intend to own a tablet anytime soon. Rather, I can't imagine phonescoop not offering them on their lineup! Well, that's probably my hubris speaking. 😛
Tablets may run on the same networks, and run similar software, and even have most of the same "guts" as phones, but that's all technical details, not the end-user experience.
Blu-ray players have the same guts as a basic desktop PC these days, and they hook up to a screen and network. But that doesn't mean PCs and Blu-ray players belong in the same category.
A tablet is really a very different type of device compared to a phone, with different use cases and therefore very different design criteria.
When you try to blur the line, it doesn't work well. Look at the Dell Streak 5; not very successful. A failure in the market, actually. Tablets and phones are distinct.
But lets say we fast forward a couple years, and tablets evolve and morph to the point that is what they are; the device you carry with you all the time. Would you include them then?
Personally, I don't see that. Too big and awkward in my book. But lets say that is where we end up...
I remember how badly I wanted an oqo back in 2007. I just do not understand how something as unwieldy as a tablet can take off but something like a cell phone-sized computer flops.
keep doing what you're doing and i will be here reading!
Also, thank you for not reporting on the Verizon iPhone until it was officially announced, instead of just inundating us with the rumors. I stopped going to other websites because of all of the rumors, and, I think Phonescoop has the best organization and is easiest to navigate. Thank you.