Review: HTC U12+
HTC's 2018 flagship is the U12+, a large Android slab with a big screen, front and rear dual cameras, see-through glass, and squeezable actions. The phone offers top specs in a modern piece of hardware that's attractive, powerful, and sadly flawed in some respects. Here is Phone Scoop's in-depth review of the HTC U12+.
AD article continues below...
Is It Your Type?
HTC's 2018 flagship, the U12+, tosses a solid set of features into an attractive, if large, piece of hardware. It also offers a few unique functions that make it stand out from the crowd of super slabs. This unlocked device runs well on AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon, so if you're looking for an alternative to carrier-store fare, the U12+ certainly fits the bill.
HTC has often pushed the envelope when it comes to design. The One X (2012) and the One M7 (2013) were stunning trendsetters. Last year, HTC cooked up the gorgeous U11 with a Liquid Glass design and has followed it up with another svelte looker in the U12+. The company knows sexy.
The U12+ is a fine piece of hardware. HTC improved its Liquid Glass design, making for a metal-and-glass phone that looks and feels luxurious. HTC picked top-notch materials for the U12+ and put the components together snugly. It's impossible to not be impressed with the quality of the glass and the rigidity of the metal frame. All the seams are tight and even around the entire frame.
The paint job on the three color variants is impressive. The Translucent Blue shade is semi-see-through so you can spy the components under the center of the rear glass. The "Flame Red" variant changes color depending on the light and can appear red, gold, or even purple. It's quite something to behold. The front and rear glass panels sandwich a strong metal frame that encircles the footprint. The frame is painted black on our review unit.
HTC did well to keep the width under 3 inches, but the phone is somewhat bigger than I want it to be. At 6.14 inches tall and 2.9 inches wide, it's about the same size/shape as the Galaxy S9+. I'm sure the U12+ may be too much phone for some people. Oddly, the phone looks and feels much thicker than its 9mm girth would attest. It measures only 1mm thicker than many competing phones, but somehow comes across as more bulky. I didn't have any trouble using the phone or carrying it around. At 6.64 ounces, it's fairly heavy. It fits into jeans pockets easily, but it weighed down my summer shorts a bit.
The U12+ is rated IP68 for protection against water and dust. This means it'll be okay if you drop it in the pool this summer, or spill a drink on it during your backyard barbeques. The U12+ is made of Gorilla Glass, but that doesn't mean it's impervious to damage when dropped. HTC generously includes a simple snap-on case in the box. I suggest you use it.
The U12+ adopts a 2:1 screen shape with no notch. The bezels are slimmer than past HTC phones while still being thicker than I prefer. The U12+ still has a bit of a forehead and a bit of a chin framing the top and bottom of the screen. The earpiece, twin user-facing cameras, and LED light are above the screen. The phone doesn't quite have the all-screen look that other 2:1 phones do, but it's a huge step in the right direction for HTC.
The U12+ carries over Edge Sense, which means the side edges are pressure-sensitive. A squeeze can activate the app or action of your choice. I like that you can dial in the sensitivity for squeezes. It takes getting used to, and I still accidentally activate it unintentionally, even though the same feature is on the Pixel 2 XL.
The screen-lock and volume buttons on the side are no longer physical buttons. Instead, they're a solid-state design, activated by the same pressure sensors as Edge Sense. HTC says it opted for this design to help achieve the watertight chassis. The "buttons" are just fixed nubs of metal; the phone's haptic motor attempts to simulate the "click" of physical buttons. It's a neat idea that I don't think HTC got quite right.
The problem is feedback. It's just not fast enough. Physical buttons provide clear feedback immediately as you press them. With these electronic buttons, there's a noticeable delay. Not only is there a delay, but I often felt it necessary to press the buttons *really hard* to get them to work — far harder than I'd have to push any real button. I do like that the screen lock button has a ribbed texture to help set it apart. The volume toggles are separate keys with smooth profiles.
You'll find the USB-C port and speaker port on the bottom. The phone does not have a 3.5mm headphone jack, which will surely grate some users. To offset that aggravation, HTC will include its capable U-Sonic headphones with active noise cancellation in the box. (These are actually decent USB-C headphones.)
The rear panel of the phone features a nice piece of curved glass that tucks into the metal frame seamlessly. Near the top you'll spot the dual-camera array, arranged side-by-side. The fingerprint reader is just below that. Most importantly, the fingerprint reader, which is indented just a bit, is easy to find and use.
This portion of the rear is where you can see the internal components on the Translucent Blue model. It's pretty neat. As much as I love the Liquid Glass, holy hell does this surface collect gross fingerprint smears.
From a hardware perspective, the U12+ is HTC's most appealing device ever. It has more personality than the LG G7, and goes toe-to-toe with class leaders such as the Samsung Galaxy S9+. I'm glad HTC adopted table-stakes features such as waterproofing and a 2:1 screen. The U12+ is a beast.
The U12+ offers the best screen I've seen on an HTC phone. The Super LCD 6 display measures 6 inches across the diagonal with 2,880 by 1,440 pixels (quad HD+). It supports HDR 10 for extra contrast. It's a rich, sharp display. The resolution is outstanding and delivers perfectly clean text, icons, and graphics. Colors are accurate and brightness is excellent. Viewing angles are very, very good. My one complaint is that the glass is highly reflective and prone to some smudging. This gets in the way of visibility outdoors or when subject to strong light. I noticed I had trouble seeing the camera, for example, when taking photos outside. I was forced to adjust brightness constantly. Other than this, it's an excellent screen.
Like most modern flagships, you can control the color profiles, set nighttime hours, resolution, and brightness on the fly. These tools are all easy to manage.
HTC sells the phone unlocked with decent support for AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon Wireless. I'm bummed it doesn't support bands 29/30 for AT&T, nor Band 71 for T-Mobile. A bit of good news: while Verizon doesn't sell the phone directly, the U12+ is certified for use on Verizon's network.
I tested it on all three of these networks in and around NYC and came away impressed. All calls connected on the first dial in good coverage areas and the first or second dial in poor coverage areas. That's typical. Further, the phone didn't drop any calls on any of the three networks even over miles of highway driving.
On the data side of the equation, things played out as I expected. T-Mobile delivered the best speeds to the U12+, though branded T-Mobile phones with Band 71 aboard do better.
Verizon offered the strongest network performance under weak and congested conditions, and the U12 matched the performance of other Verizon phones I have on hand. We can thank Verizon's certification process for this.
The U12+'s performance AT&T ranked third in my tests, but not by much. The phone performed just under par when compared to branded AT&T phones with Bands 29/30.
The U12+ did well enough on all three, offering seamless media streaming, quick social media browsing, and solid web speeds.
HTC crafted a fine voice phone in the U12+. The majority of calls I placed sounded clean and warm, although the volume level left me wanting more. I struggled to hear calls while walking city streets or sitting in noisy coffee shops. Some more punch would have been nice, but at least the quality is there.
The speakerphone is the inverse. Volume is outstanding, but clarity isn't as good. Calls are easy to hear pretty much anywhere you take the phone. Voices are more prone to distortion and breakup when pushed out of the speakerphone. The improvement in volume makes up for the occasional snap-crackle-pop.
HTC improved its BoomSound speakers. Not only is the amplifier able to generate 30% louder music, the two speakers (earpiece and bottom-firing) deliver more balance between highs and lows. The result is a better experience when holding the phone in landscape orientation. I compared it to other phones that use a similar "stereo" speaker arrangement and would say it is on par with the LG G7 and iPhone X.
Thanks to the improved amplifier, ringers and alerts are awesomely loud and always got my attention. The vibrate motor is a bit weak.
The included USonic headphones measure and map your inner ear and use phone-based software to analyze and adjust the sound profile specifically for the shape of your ear canal. What's more, the USonic headphones include active noise cancellation. The results are real. The customized sound profiles and active noise cancellation make the USonics some of the best in-box headphones around.
Battery life is wildly inconsistent. The phone has a 3,500mAh battery inside. In theory, it should deliver a full day's use without breaking a sweat. It sweats a lot.
The problem is standby battery drain. On at least a half-dozen occasions the phone lost 20% - 50% of battery capacity over the course of several hours with no use at all; no screen time, nothing, just sitting there. (The battery management tool attributed the drain mostly to Google Play Services.) HTC insists this is abnormal behavior and is looking into it. Other reviewers have reported similar issues, so we don't think it is a problem with our specific review unit.
On the flip side, I was able to stream YouTube videos for 10 hours straight over WiFi with no issues whatsoever. When you actually use the phone the battery seems to perform as it should. It's a conundrum to be sure.
The phone includes HTC's Power Saver mode, which conserves CPU cycles, limits location services, reduces screen brightness, and turns off vibration. The Ultra Power Saver mode is more dramatic; it basically turns the U12+ into a heavy feature phone, which means you can access the phone, messaging, and email apps, but nothing else.
Disappointingly, the U12+ cannot charge wirelessly — making it one of the few 2018 flagship phones missing this feature. The phone supports Quick Charge 3.0 and HTC was kind enough to stick a QC3 charger in the box.
Bluetooth, GPS, NFC, WiFi
HTC did a fine job with the U12+'s secondary radios. The Bluetooth radio worked as expected. I paired it with a number of headphones and speakers, as well as my car. Call quality through my car's hands-free system was excellent. Music streamed via Bluetooth to my favorite headphones sounded amazing thanks to aptX HD.
The NFC radio helped me pair the U12+ with compatible accessories, such as Bluetooth speakers. The phone also supports Android Pay for mobile payments. I didn't run into any issues setting up and using Google's mobile payment service on the U12+.
The U12+ performed GPS functions with ease. Google Maps always pinpointed me in just a couple of seconds to within 10 feet. It doesn't get much better than that. Real-time navigation ran smoothly and kept up with me at highway speeds.
The WiFi radio handled tasks such as downloading apps with aplomb. It's worth pointing out that the U12+ supports Apple Airplay, a rarity for Android phones. This lets it bean media to an Apple TV, for example. The phone also supports DLNA and Miracast for sharing with compatible equipment.
The U12+ runs Android 8 Oreo with HTC's Sense interface on top.
HTC calls its ambient display "Smart Display". It shows the time and basic notifications on the screen as they arrive. You can control when this feature is active, such as during daytime hours, as well as how much information is displayed. I love that HTC has so many different options for the clock, time, and date arrangements.
Tap the screen, squeeze the sides, or press the lock button to fully wake the display. The lock screen shows the clock, notifications, and shortcuts. The shortcuts mirror those set in your home screen dock. I like that the clock includes the weather details for your current location.
The U12+'s rear-mounted fingerprint sensor is easy to train and easy to use. The U12+'s sensor is on par with the fingerprint readers on other flagship phones in terms of speed and reliability. It's very good. It's a shame that the fingerprint reader does not support gestures such as scrolling or opening the notification shade. You can, however, tap the fingerprint reader when using the camera to take a quick shot.
The phone supports a simple face unlock tool based on the user-facing camera. It takes less than a minute to train and works pretty well. HTC warns that it is not the most secure way to lock the phone. I think the fingerprint reader is the quickest and most reliable way to unlock the phone, and it's secure.
HTC's home screen experience is tired and needs to change — or just go away. The Sense user interface skin has had the same fonts and basic appearance for years. I find it beyond stale and unwelcome at this point. Granted, HTC lets you install themes and make other changes to Sense's basic appearance, but it still stands as one of the heavier-handed skins and feels overwrought. (To be fair, the skins from LG and Samsung are not much better.)
I think Motorola and OnePlus (and, heck, even ZTE and Kyocera) have found the right balance of introducing tasteful features that are truly helpful while keeping the experience as close to Google's excellent design as possible.
The core home screen experience is fairly straightforward. The app drawer allows users to arrange apps alphabetically, in custom order, or via recents. It also lets you change the size of the grid. The app drawer includes a search tool and supports folders.
Blinkfeed, HTC's social newsreader, is active as the left-most home screen panel of the U12+. You can use it to generate a feed from Twitter, Facebook, and a handful of third-party news sources. I wish it didn't include ads. You can disable Blinkfeed completely if you wish and I recommend you ignore it (particularly if you already make use of Google's feed.)
Amazon Alexa is onboard, and Dual Wake Words means you can speak to either Alexa or Google Assistant as you please. HTC says it improved its microphones for better far-field (across-the-room) recognition. The phone almost always jumped to life when I asked it to, whether it was Alexa or Google doing the waking.
Sense Companion, HTC's spin on the device-side assistant, is on board too. It's more like Samsung's Bixby than Google's Assistant — which is to say I don't really recommend it. You'll need to activate the service, walk through some basic settings, and give it permission to offer suggestions. Over time, Sense Companion will tell you when there's traffic, warn you about upcoming calendar events, record and display your fitness data and such. There's nothing wrong with the concept, but Google already does most of this, and Google is just better at this stuff.
Last, HTC added what it calls the Edge Launcher. Calling up the launcher adds a spinning wheel of app shortcuts to the right side of the screen. If you are nimble fingered you can quickly dial the wheel and open any app you want from inside other apps without returning to the home screen. There's something very similar on Samsung devices. It's sort of a power user multitasking function. It also provides a quick look at the calendar and can include contacts, quick-dial actions, and more.
The U12+ is powered by the top-of-the-line Qualcomm Snapdragon 845 chip, with 6 GB of RAM. The phone ran swiftly with no issues whatsoever. All of the apps opened in a blink and screen transitions were fluid. The Snapdragon 845 gives the U12+ all the power it needs.
There's no shortage of ways to fire up the camera. The camera can be opened via Edge Sense (squeezing the phone), a double press of the screen lock button, the lock screen shortcut, and the home screen icon. The camera opens quickly.
A few settings are available from the camera's main viewfinder screen, including the flash and HDR. Both of these can be set to on, off, or auto. You can also jump between picture aspect ratios, set a timer, or quickly launch the sticker tool. The U12+ has separate buttons for snapping pictures and capturing video, and a useful slider for managing zoom.
Camera modes are accessible from a drawer you swipe open, and they include photo, panorama, pro, video, hyperlapse, slow-motion, selfie photo, selfie pano, and selfie video.
The Pro mode is a manual mode that gives you control over white balance, exposure, ISO, shutter speed (up to 32 seconds), and focal points. The sliding tools for adjusting these are straightforward. You can save three custom Pro shooting modes as presets if you wish. Pro mode also allows you to capture RAW images, which offer more potential for fixing exposure and white balance after the fact. It's a really powerful and manageable Pro mode.
The other shooting modes behave more or less how you expect them to. I wish the slow-mo tool let you make adjustments to capture speed. The U12+ doesn't support anything like 960fps.
The dedicated selfie mode includes a screen-based flash to help with low-light shooting. You have access to tons of animated stickers that you can apply in real-time to your face as you snap selfies.
Once you learn to navigate the app, which has a lot of ins and outs, the camera is quick.
HTC overhauled the camera system this year. The main camera has a 12-megapixel, wide-angle sensor at f/1.75 and a secondary 16-megapixel telephoto sensor at f/2.6. The camera includes a hybrid of phase detection and laser autofocus. The phone supports optical zoom up to 2x via the dual cameras.
I was happy with the photos I captured with the U12+. Most importantly, shots were accurate to the lighting and conditions I saw. Some pix I captured of downtown NYC on a dreary day are absolutely true to life. They were sharp, perfectly exposed, and showed proper color. I spent an evening shooting a concert with the U12+ and it really impressed me. The zoom function did very well, even in the dark, though there was plenty of grain in the results. Shooting around my house cemented my appreciation for the phone, which takes fine photos.
The front has two 8-megapixel cameras at f/2.0 with support for bokeh portraits, HDR, live makeup, AR stickers, and panorama selfies. It does pretty well. The selfies I took at a concert — without the benefit of beautification — turned out more accurate than I might have preferred. Still, the shots were sharp, colorful, and properly exposed. I like the option for wide-angle selfies.
The video camera includes a feature called Sonic Zoom, which will tweak the microphones to focus more narrowly when users zoom in on a subject. It works, but almost imperceptibly. You need to listen to the results on a decent home theater system to really get the effect. The U12+ can capture 4K video and includes OIS to reduce shake. There's no question it produces sharp video, even in dark settings. The multiple microphones weren't quite able to handle the sonic blast of a heavy metal show, which overpowered the phone and left me with distorted results.
The U12+ is one of the first phones to add Google Lens directly to the camera app. It's a cinch to perform image-based searches right from the camera viewfinder. Results aren't perfect, but they are helpful from time to time.
HTC put in a lot of effort to improve its Edge Sense system along the metal sides of the U12+, and the results are uneven, if not awful.
Pressure sensors are buried under the metal frame at/below the phone's waist. Squeezing these sides calls up different actions. The new Edge Sense 2 can do much more, though. For example, a double-tap on one side will shrink the screen to one-handed mode. This works well.
As long as you hold it in a normal one-handed grip, you can set the screen to maintain portrait orientation even when sideways. This is a helpful feature for those who like to browse in bed, but it takes practice to use.
As before, users can customize a quick squeeze to open Google Assistant, Amazon Alexa, fire off a picture, and more. Edge Sense continues to work even when the phone is in a case. Setting up all these behaviors and managing how well they work depends on the sensitivity level you select for the squeezing options and whether or not you can remember what actions you've assigned to short squeeze versus long squeezes.
I had a heck of a time getting the sensitivity where I wanted it, and every now and then I felt like the sensitivity preferences would randomly reset. I also experienced phantom input. The phone would act like I was squeezing it even though I wasn't. Other times, I squeezed it and nothing happened. It's just not reliable. Clearly something is amiss.
The HTC U12+ is an incredibly advanced smartphone that somehow bungles a couple of core features, thereby sidelining the whole thing. It's maddening.
In the plus column, we have the sultry design, the pleasing build, the gorgeous screen, and the waterproof chassis. Radio performance was good enough, and voice calls got the job done. Music sounds great whether you're listening via HTC's USonic headphones or the U12+'s BoomSound speakers. A fast processor with lots of RAM, plenty of storage, and capable cameras really help the U12+ impress.
The negatives, however, are really negative. Battery life is the most worrisome issue. The inconsistency I saw over more than a week of testing left me not trusting the phone. Then there are the buttons. I never got the hang of them. The electronic side keys just aren't as quick or as responsive as real buttons would be and the experience slows you down. The burdensome software doesn't help. While I appreciate having options, HTC's everything-and-the-kitchen-sink approach left me feeling overwhelmed at times.
HTC sells the U12+ online unlocked for $800. That's a lot for a phone with questionable battery life and weird buttons. Though I really like aspects of this phone, I think your money may be better spent right now on alternatives like the LG G7, V35, or Galaxy S9+.
Have your eye on a shiny new phone, but it isn't sold by Verizon Wireless? Did you know that Big Red allows you to bring your own device to its network?
HTC's 2018 flagship is the U12+, a phone that aims directly at competing devices such as the Samsung Galaxy S9+, LG G7, and iPhone X. The U12+ sees HTC adopting the 2:1 screen aspect ratio, dialing back the bezels, and carrying over the luscious liquid design from last year's phone.
Aug 17, 2018
HTC today made its flagship phone available in a third color option. Consumers interested in a red phone can now pick that instead of black or blue.
Aug 1, 2018
HTC is pushing a system update to the U12 that includes a number of adjustments for the phone. To start, the update adds two new features: auto zoom when recording video, and 4K video capture at 30fps with no time limit.
May 23, 2018
HTC today announced the U12+, its flagship handset for the year. The phone carries over the "liquid design" from last year's U11, but updates the color selection for the metal-and-glass chassis.