Home  ›  Phones  ›  Motorola  ›

Motorola V710

 

Info Photos News Forum Reviews  100+  

all discussions

show all 12 replies

Verizon's position on broken V710 Bluetooth

dsnelson

Nov 27, 2004, 8:44 PM
I contacted Verizon today and basically grilled them over the crippled bluetooth in the v710, and here is their response:


"We appreciate your interest in the incorporation of Bluetooth Technology with Verizon Wireless services. This is correct we have crippled some of the Bluetooth functions to insure the security of America's best, most reliable wireless network so this network is not destroyed or crippled by a internet virus that can be transferred via Bluetooth. There is a 15 day no questions asked return period if you wish to switch phones or return to old phone."


For starters, their English is a bit lumpy. (Maybe they're in Bombay!) 🤣

Second, I totally do not believe that horse-doodoo about viruses via Blueto...
(continues)
...
wirehead

Nov 28, 2004, 10:30 PM
dsnelson said:
Second, I totally do not believe that horse-doodoo about viruses via Bluetooth. You can reprogram these phones via RF... they're not afraid of that, though.


Dude, I'm the dude who's most likely to defend Verizon and *I* think that's, for the most part, a load of crap.

Here's the thing.... All of the Bluetooth exploits are, for the most part, brought about by poor implementation. So it would make good business sense, especially because the Bluejacking story has legs lately, to not have OBEX until you've had a chance to audit your codebase and make sure that none of the Bluejacking exploits are possible with the v710. But most of those exploits don't work against Motorola phones, so it'...
(continues)
...
dsnelson

Nov 28, 2004, 11:49 PM
wirehead said:
Here's the thing.... All of the Bluetooth exploits are, for the most part, brought about by poor implementation. So it would make good business sense, especially because the Bluejacking story has legs lately, to not have OBEX until you've had a chance to audit your codebase and make sure that none of the Bluejacking exploits are possible with the v710. But most of those exploits don't work against Motorola phones, so it's most likely not a huge problem.


Yeah, the fact that you have to be so close to establish Bluetooth contact makes infection seem highly unlikely, plus most folks (myself included) would likely leave it off until needed, since it's a battery drain.

wirehe
...
(continues)
...
wirehead

Nov 29, 2004, 12:26 AM
dsnelson said:
Yeah, the fact that you have to be so close to establish Bluetooth contact makes infection seem highly unlikely, plus most folks (myself included) would likely leave it off until needed, since it's a battery drain.


Actually.....

If you want to just Bluejack somebody, you just make a pringles-can 2.4 GHz antenna.

And if you were spreading viruses, just think about a downtown city street. You'd get close to quite a lot of people.

Then picture each and every one of those phones placing calls and sending SMSes at the exact same time -- remember, every phone knows the current time if it's going to work on a CDMA network -- bringing down the network for a continuous hour.
...
spiff

Nov 29, 2004, 8:50 AM
I understand your theory here but let me ask you this -- Don't you need to accept an invitation for bluetooth to work?? I mean the v710 isn't in discovery mode unless you put it there. so unless you have the misfortune to be walking down that city street and piaring your phone to your headset then theperson trying to install the virus wouldn't even see your phone. let alone everyone's on the street even if the phones were on. The phone doesn't support dual lines of connection so if the bluetooth were on and in use the phone would not open another connection just to recieve the virus

a blutooth virus on this phone is not to my knowledge a viable thing.

rob
...
uNt0uChAbLe

Nov 29, 2004, 11:36 AM
He is saying that if OBEX was on the phone there is a chance that it could be left on like on other BT phones. And no you do not need to accept/decline any BT invitation. Hackers can bypass anything they want to so I am sure that they have found out a way to bypass you accpeting the BT connection. But like he said before its all about trying to make money thru GIN. Its a good business plan and the majority of the people who have the v710 dont really care or even know what OBEX is.
...
ibeetle

Nov 29, 2004, 11:47 AM
You are completely right. My little brother has the nokia n-gage. First it will tell you you have a message. When you access the message if it is from someone not in the address book it will tell you that it is from an untrusted source. Then when you try to open it you get the same warning and to proceed with caution. Then if it trys to auto install it will give a warning and ask permission to install?

The only way you can send a file with a virus in it to a phone is first you need to be within 30 feet for the n-gage at least.

Say standing in line at a movie theater.

Then you need to know the persons number call them to send the data.

This could be done with a scanner. But the scanner needed is the size of a shoe box... a lit...
(continues)
...
wirehead

Nov 29, 2004, 2:03 PM
spiff said:
I understand your theory here but let me ask you this -- Don't you need to accept an invitation for bluetooth to work??


See, that's the thing.

Some of the Bluetooth phones have a variety of bugs in their implementations that are discoverable all of the time, either by intent or because of some sort of accidental bug.

Or, alternatively, let users make their phone always discoverable. Because history bears me out when I say that most people forget that radio waves go in all directions, not just where it's immediately most convenient for them to go, it's pretty much a given that if you let people have their phones always pairable, always discoverable, at least a good percentage of them wil...
(continues)
...
ibeetle

Nov 29, 2004, 3:25 PM
Nope. Try a iPaq or other similar PDA with built-in Bluetooth.


I do not believe you can find out my phone number or bluethooth device registration number with any bluetooth device like a PDA.

You cannot use a PDA as a scanner. My information comes from a close relative who's job is to basically turn physics into computer code and who worked on the ARPANet at Columbia University.
...
dsnelson

Nov 30, 2004, 8:39 AM
wirehead said:
If you want to just Bluejack somebody, you just make a pringles-can 2.4 GHz antenna.


Can you do that with Bluetooth? I know it works with wi-fi.

I dunno, our PCs are far more capable of creating/transmitting viruses, but the ISPs don't break them for us to "protect the network". The whole thing reeks of bait-and-switch.

--Dave
...
wirehead

Nov 30, 2004, 2:11 PM
Okay, so we'll start with a definition of terms:

IrDA = Wireless cable replacement over infrared. Very focused and directional
802.11b / 802.11g / WiFi = 2.4 GHz wireless "Ethernet" networking
802.11a = 5.4/5.8 GHz wireless "Ethernet" networking
Bluetooth = 2.4 GHz wireless cable replacement, and the intellectual successor to IrDA
Cantenna = One of the many easy-to-make-at-home high-gain (meaning you have a focused signal beam with long range, like a spotlight vs. a light bulb) antennas. Pringles cans are usually used.

Now, the first thing to remember is that, yes, Wifi and Bluetooth are on the same frequency. Microwaves and some cordless phones also share the band. Sometimes they stomp on each other. If your Microwave is inte...
(continues)
...
pemarsh

Dec 1, 2004, 2:11 AM
We all still have the same problem...just no solution....not becuase of a lack of trying.

I have called moto and vzw numberous times...but it really is frustrating to listen to idiots make things up, and who dont even know what obex is, let alone what bluetooth tech is all about.

I just wish I knew how to reach someone who actually knows something at moto or vzw.
...
dsnelson

Dec 1, 2004, 8:54 AM
Thanks for the lesson, wirehead.

--Dave
...

You must log in to reply.

Please log in to report a message to the moderator.


all discussions

Subscribe to Phone Scoop News with RSS Follow @phonescoop on Threads Follow @phonescoop on Mastodon Phone Scoop on Facebook Follow on Instagram

 

Playwire

All content Copyright 2001-2024 Phone Factor, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Content on this site may not be copied or republished without formal permission.