Sony Ericsson Z600

Might be a bit alarmist, but flat out saying it's wrong isn't correct either. They aren't phasing out the 1800 band, but at least in virtually all of Oregon, most of Washington (except the hotbed of 3G Seattle), San Diego, Chicago, New York and Houston, the 850 band gets far better coverage area and penetration through buildings. It's lower frequency so it travels further and penetrates better. I would agree that it would be stupid to get this phone for AT&T, but I've had terrible RF performance with every other SE phone I've ever tried with AT&T, so I'm not about to try this one. I live on the fringe and the only phones that reliably work are Nokias.