Review: Samsung Instinct

Is it possible to accept that maybe, just mayybe, this phone did not live up to everyones review expectations? I guess it is possible that they got a lemon to review, but if everyone feels so strongly against the review, ignore it and go get your Instinct when it's released.
Your experience with the phone will not be the same as Phonescoop's, this just very well maybe your dream phone. Why bash the review, a better question would be: Why does everyone want this phone to do so well? I have my hopes up for this phone as well, but some people are calling out for blood after reading the review.