Moto's Tests Show HSDPA Disappoints In Real World

nextel18 said:
that is why the trial and the real world are very different..

anyone have any opinions?

are we going to see 14mb/s or at least 1.8mb/s?

I thought the article mentioned Motorola is the compa...
(continues)

I don't see it would be any different from EV-DO...where Rev A is faster than the first release....

I don't expect the first release of HSDPA to be the "best" one.

nextel18 said:
that is why the trial and the real world are very different..

anyone have any opinions?

are we going to see 14mb/s or at least 1.8mb/s?

Give it some time before you use words such as "alleged"...
(continues)

Same here.
Their video shows decent results - I'm not sure what the writer is looking for. According to the video, they were averaging 2.3 Mbps while driving at 50 km/h, and averaged 2.5 Mbps stationary at the edge of cell.

muchdrama said:
...but I'm willing to wait till Cingular gets their HSDPA fully functional before I start making assumptions.

Given Motorola's history of making good ideas look bad in the real world, I think I'll wa...
(continues)

I agree with you on this one. It seems that time could become a foe to Cingular. Can they afford to allow their CDMA counterparts to develop and deploy future versions of EVDO? Given Sprint's history of deploying new network technology quickly across ...
(continues)